A Not-So-Silly Craft Idea: Make Your Own Nutty Putty

A few weeks ago, we turned a rainy day into a pretty good time by making our own play dough. Much as I’d prefer to be outside soaking up what’s left of summer, rain seems to be the standard forecast these days. Still, we managed to find a good time in our usual DIY fashion. This week we tried our hand at a new craft for kids (and adults, too!): homemade nutty putty.

What is nutty putty anyway? You may know it best as Crayola’s Silly Putty. But the story of this classic toy starts during World War II, when rubber shortages were profound. In an attempt to create a viable synthetic rubber, engineer James Wright combined boric acid and silicone oil and discovered the results had interesting properties. It bounced high, stretched far and melted only at high temperatures. Although it didn’t turn out to be the rubber substitute he had hoped for, as a novelty it was a great success. Thus, nutty putty was born and within a few years became the “must have” toy of the 1950′s.

When a friend passed along a recipe she had found for a homemade version, I was intrigued. By combining Elmer’s glue and liquid starch, we enjoyed a revelation similar to that of James Wright. This stuff bounces, it stretches, it lifts pictures out of the funny papers and it doesn’t stick to clothes. This magic has something to do with the glue’s properties as a liquid polymer causing molecules to strand together when introduced to the liquid starch.

Man, I love science.

Ready to give homemade putty a try? It takes just a few minutes, and older kids will have no trouble making their own with adult supervision. Rainy day optional.


Step 1

 Open Gallery

Pour ½ cup Elmer’s Glue-All into a glass or plastic container.

Step 2

 Open Gallery

Add food coloring to the glue and stir using a craft stick. Choose any color and add as much as needed to reach the desired effect (we used 20 drops of purple here).

Step 3

 Open Gallery

Once the color is even, add ½ cup of liquid starch and stir.

Step 4

 Open Gallery

The consistency will soon become rubbery. As soon as the glue “stands up” (as shown), stop stirring and let the mix rest 3-4 minutes to allow the starch to completely permeate the thickening glue.

Step 5

 Open Gallery

Remove the putty from the remaining starch and pat with a paper towel to remove excess starch.

Step 6

 Open Gallery

Knead the putty until it becomes firm and pliant.

Step 7

 Open Gallery

The putty will become less slick and will become firmer the longer it is kneaded. After a couple of minutes, it is still softer than we’re after. Keep kneading!

Step 8

 Open Gallery

After 5-10 minutes of kneading, our putty is firm, stretches easily and is ready for action. Pennies to make. Hours of fun. This recipe makes plenty, so be sure to share with a friend!


  • Elmer’s Glue-All
  • Food coloring (color of your choice)
  • Liquid starch
  • Paper towels


  • Glass or plastic containers
  • Wooden craft stick
About Mick Telkamp 


A former Midwesterner living in North Carolina, I write about my adventures in backyard chicken-keeping and suburban homesteading over at HGTVGardens, and my exploits in the culture of Southern cooking ...

More About Mick Telkamp

3 Responses

  1. e-forex says:

    Tell my toddler? Many moments students really don�t even find out why they can be feeling frightened. It might be essential that you don�t fire loads of questions in your child

  2. Erinn Smith says:

    Love IT! We will be doing this one~

  3. Grannynanny says:

    Nutty putty is childhood revisited !

Leave a Reply

More Posts Like This One

Latest Pins on Pinterest

  • Make no-sew his and

    Make no-sew his and hers pillows >>

  • Valentine's party ph

    Valentine's party photo booth ideas and kids'

  • Free printable valen

    Free printable valentine's day banners +

  • Plan a romantic brea

    Plan a romantic breakfast in bed for you and your

More Great Blogs

  • no items!